Author Archives: Josh Perry

What Cost Reduction Strategies Make New Product Introductions Faster?

Getting to markets faster and in the most cost-effective way is the primary goal of today’s product development process. Choosing a thermal design engineering partner that understands that goal makes a company’s product realization process simpler and faster. There are number of strategies a company’s project engineers can use to save time and money in the design of an electronics cooling solution. Two of the most efficient methods are Virtual Engineering Demos (VED) and Thermal Load Boards (TLB).

VEDs make it possible for project engineers to remotely see an instrument, how it operates, ask questions about how it works, and, if the project is included in the demo, get data in real time about a design. In this method, a live demo is setup at a thermal design engineering partner’s laboratory. Whether the project is a PCB, a system, or another product type, it can be included in the VED and be run through the lab set-up.

Greg Wong

ATS engineer Greg Wong gives a live, online demonstration from the ATS research lab to a potential customer. (John O’Day/Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

Candlestick Sensor

ATS engineer Greg Wong sets up to demonstrate the ATVS-2020, Candlestick Sensors and StageVIEW Data Acquisition Software (DAQ) for measuring and analyzing temperature for an electronics board in this VED. (Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

VED in Lab

Equipment setup and live camera feeds are all part of a VED setup. (Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

As the project is analyzed, data is shown on the engineering partner’s computer screen, which is in turn broadcast in real time to the project engineers via a live video feed. The video feed simultaneously shows the demo and the software’s operation, while allowing bi-directional conversation between the engineering partner and the project engineers in one or more locations.

stageVIEW_software

Screenshot showing data being recorded in stageVIEW. This information is available to the remote team. (Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

The advantages of this strategy to project engineers are:

• Quick evaluation of a design to determine if there is a need for new equipment in a project.
• No lag time in talking with a thermal design engineering partner about how to approach the thermal measurement of project
• Reducing the need to travel to a thermal design engineering partner’s lab.
• Faster response on lab testing, shortening the design cycle.

A Thermal Load Board (TLB) is another strategy for reducing the cost of a design, while getting a product to market faster. TLBs are created by a thermal engineering partner using a simple one- or two- layer non-populated PCB, heat sinks, thermally equivalent mock semiconductors and other mock components created with a 3-D printer.

TLB 3-D printing

Using these components a populated board is created that allows the testing of the heat sinks chosen for the project work and measurement of the airflow over the components and through the board. (Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

The thermal engineering partner is effectively creating a mock version of the functional board. The design of the TLB is based on the size and placement of the semiconductors and other components on the actual board, which is provided by the project engineers, and provides a cheaper and quicker means of producing a prototype for testing. The data from that testing will in turn expedite the design process and time to market.

This can be a very cost-effective method for doing heat sink characterization for the following reasons:

• It reduces electronic system development cost.
o A system developer can focus on thermal issues very quickly instead of waiting for an expensive prototype to come out of the factory.
o Rather than using a potentially expensive project, testing on prototypes can determine design flaws without requiring a significant
cost.
o Because prototypes are less expensive, each iteration of a design can quickly go through an initial series of tests.
• It reduces time to market.
o Valuable resources can be applied to engineering the best solution because a load board can generally be created in 1-2 weeks and at a
fraction of the cost of a full PCB.
• It allows a physical testing very early in the design.
o Many times components on a PCB will obstruct air flow, requiring either costly design changes during NPI (new product introduction) or
requiring engineers to over-design a board and the thermal management solution, putting the product outside its cost objective.

After a thermal load board is created, the board is ready to be used:

Completed Load Board

A completed load board ready for testing. (Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.)

The heaters on the board can be powered up to dissipate the same level of power as the semiconductors they are meant to represent. Heat sinks can then be applied based on initial analysis done via integral modeling, mathematical modeling or through CFD (computational fluid dynamics). To test just air flow, heat sinks can even be created by 3-D printing.

Once populated with heat sinks, the board can be tested in a wind tunnel to see if the air flow will be sufficient. Wind tunnel testing methods include smoke flow visualization or water tunnel testing in order to examine air flow and ensure the most functional and cost-effective design is applied.

Getting to market faster and with the best possible design is very important in today’s product development process. Working with a thermal engineering partner, such as Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc. (ATS), that offers Virtual Engineering Demos (VED) and Thermal Load Boards (TLB) will benefit a project’s bottom line and ensure a project’s successful completion. Project engineers will know that their design has proper thermal management early in the process, meaning that they will not have to over-design the project, which will save time and money in the long run.

Learn more about ATS and its capabilities as a thermal engineering partner for your next project by visiting www.qats.com or by calling 781-769-2800.

References:

Thermal Load Board Design Considerations


http://www.3dsystems.com/learning-center/case-studies/lowering-cost-and-reducing-production-time-projet-3d-printing-lets

Electric Car Batteries Are Topic of Presentation by ATS CEO Dr. Kaveh Azar

Electric Car Batteries

ATS CEO Dr. Kaveh Azar will deliver a presentation on the thermal management of electric vehicle batteries on Thursday, Sept. 22. (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

On Thursday, Sept. 22, Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc. (ATS), a leading-edge engineering and manufacturing company focused on the thermal management of electronics, will host the New England Section of Society of Automotive Engineers International (SAE NE) for a tour of its Norwood campus and a presentation by ATS founder, President, and CEO Dr. Kaveh Azar.

Dr. Azar’s discussion is entitled, “Battery Thermal Management – The Gateway to the Successful Operation of Electric Vehicles.” He will review the role of temperature in the longevity and performance of nickel metal hydride (NiMH) and lithium-ion electric vehicle batteries; drawing analogies between battery temperature and the junction temperature of modern electronics. As Dr. Azar notes, “Both play an identical role in successful operation of their respective systems.”

There will be a discussion of the analytical methods and design criterion for predicting battery temperature and establishing safe temperature limits. Dr. Azar will present high-level possibilities for thermal management in the electric vehicle sphere as well as cooling options that are deployed for battery thermal management. Current cooling designs can be active or passive. There are forced air, liquid cooling, natural convection and conduction systems used by manufacturers.

Several thermal solutions that engineers have incorporated include increasing the thermal density of the battery, using phase-change material to store transient heat loads and graphite-impregnated paraffin waxes as gap fillers. It is also important for the designs to control temperature distribution across the battery to avoid degradation of cells.

Thermal management is crucial in the design of electric vehicle batteries because temperature has a direct correlation on battery life and performance. It will affect the battery’s ability to store and deliver a charge, weaken polymer- or fiber-based cell dividers, and could potentially lead to thermal runaway.

“The engineers who will design the next hybrid vehicle battery packs will need to be cognizant of the growing need for thermal management,” read a recent article on coolingZONE. “The increased need for thermal protection, due to safety considerations; the reduced thermal capacity, due to lesser mass; and the reduced workable volume are among the challenges to be faced. The hybrid vehicle we may soon drive must have reliable and intelligent cooling systems to cool down their high-density battery packs.”

Why is this topic of particular relevance now?

Electric vehicle sales worldwide have jumped 57 percent from 2015 to 2016, according to data reported by Bloomberg New Energy Finance. The article referenced a Bloomberg report stating that electric vehicle sales could be as much as 47 percent of the automotive market by 2040 (dependent on factors such as oil prices). In the U.S., manufacturers have been urged by President Barack Obama’s EV Everywhere challenge to make electric cars as affordable and convenient as gas-powered vehicles by 2022.

Like cell phone technology in the past two decades, electric vehicles have the potential for widespread usage and to wide-ranging effects inside and outside of the automotive industry. The “digitization of the transport system” will effect, among others, oil companies, car dealerships, maintenance services, and utility suppliers.

“If it is hard to predict when phase change in complex systems begins, it is even harder to predict where it ends,” said Michael Leibreich and Angus McCrone, the authors of the Bloomberg article. “No list of potential impacts of the ‘Transformation of Transportation’ can be complete. However, one thing is for sure: if our predictions for the uptake of electric vehicles are anything like correct, there is no part of the global economy which will not, in some way, be affected.”

Currently, electric vehicles cost an average of $30,000 and travel 100 miles or less on a single charge. Tesla (Model 3) and Chevrolet (Bolt EV) have both promised electric vehicles that will travel 200 miles on a charge within the year. Other car makers, such as Volkswagen and BMW, have announced plans to turn a large portion of their production to electric vehicles in the next few years as well.

While the changes in infrastructure and the length of time that most car owners keep a vehicle (11 years on average) have limited electric vehicle sales to this point, according to Christopher Mims of the Wall Street Journal, the next vehicle that most consumers purchase is likely to be electric.

Mims explained, “It is the nature of disruptive technological shifts that it seems like nothing is changing—until it seems as if everything is changing at once. Electric vehicles have been a long time coming, but they now represent such a clear and present threat to the gasoline engine that Mr. Fox, of the service-station association, now recommends that members signing long-term contracts for fuel include an option to renegotiate if more than 10 percent of a state’s fleet goes electric.”

Electric vehicles offer a smooth drive with better acceleration, less moving parts requiring less maintenance, better air quality, and a better platform for autonomous driving, said Bloomberg. Electric vehicles are the future and that means designing better, longer-lasting, higher-performing batteries will be the future as well.

Cooling those batteries will be critical. As Dr. Azar will explain, without proper thermal management the electric vehicle battery will be inefficient and unable to provide the performance that consumers demand.

The Sept. 22 event is free for SAE NE members and $5 for non-members. It runs from 6-9:15 p.m. with tours of the ATS campus from 7-8:00 p.m. and Dr. Azar’s presentation at 8:00. Register online at http://www.sae.org/servlets/sectionEvent?PAGE=getSectionEvents&OBJECT_TYPE=SectionEventAdmin&HEIR_CODE=MS045#249128&saetkn=w1aFMMls8Y or contact SAE member Jeff Mobed at [email protected] or 508-367-6565.

ATS Summer Intern Shares Her Positive Experience

ATS Intern

Rachel, a 2016 summer intern at Advanced Thermal Solutions, describes the positive learning experience she had at ATS.

Rachel, a 2016 summer marketing intern at Advanced Thermal Solutions (ATS), recently sat down to discuss her experiences with the company, what she learned, and her favorite moments. From search engine optimization to the importance of a strong web presence to utilizing social media in the B2B market, Rachel said that she learned a lot about marketing a company such as ATS.

Among her favorite memories was National Thermal Engineer Day on July 24, which was created by ATS in 2015 to recognize the impact of thermal engineer because without the contributions of thermal engineers, the electronics that are an integral part of today’s life and the cornerstone of this nation’s technological advancement would not be possible.There was a cookout at ATS’ Norwood campus and a lot of fun for the staff, as seen below:

ATS Intern

To explore an internship opportunity like Rachel had this summer, contact Advanced Thermal Solutions at [email protected].

Hear what Rachel had to say about her time at ATS in the video below:

Integral Modeling Is First Step for ATS Engineers

Integral Modeling

ATS engineers utilize integral or analytical modeling as a first step to solving thermal management issues in a design. [Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc.]

In July, Future Facilities, a CAD software company, released the results of a survey it conducted of more than 350 electrical engineers (the link to the story is below) on how thermal management relates to reliability in electronics design. The survey coincided with the release of the company’s newest version of its thermal simulation software 6SigmaET.

Forty percent of the surveyed engineers believed thermal simulations for their projects to be too time-consuming or complex. Sixty-two percent of the engineers said that they would rather over-design a project than optimize thermal performance in the design process. In fact, 33 percent of the engineers called thermal issues an “irritation” and would prefer to not deal with them.

Tom Gregory, Product Manager at 6SigmaET, concluded, “It’s clear that a lot of engineers still don’t feel comfortable creating thermal simulations of their designs, a fact which is not being helped by the complex nature of most thermal simulation tools currently on the market.”

The engineers at Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc. (ATS), a leading-edge engineering and manufacturing company focused on the thermal management of electronics, have long demonstrated that thermal solutions are a critical component to electronics design and that incorporating thermal management early in the design process will lead to a more cost-effective and reliable product.

By incorporating thermal management into the design process engineers optimize time between failure for individual components as well as the overall system. They actually reduce the cost of the system by limiting the need to overdesign it. Well thought out thermal solutions increase the likelihood that the final design will succeed and meet the specifications that were set out at the beginning of the project.

The survey results pointed to CFD analysis as the jumping off point for thermal solutions. But an easier and more efficient way to start the process is with an integral or analytical model, using pencil and paper or a spreadsheet.  In its 3-Core Design Process, ATS has utilized integral modeling as its first step to quickly and easily provide first order solutions and determine whether a design will succeed in meeting its thermal requirements.

Integral modeling, as Dr. Kaveh Azar, founder, President, and CEO of ATS, explained in a webinar (the link is below), utilizes standard equations based on the basic laws that govern thermal engineering: Conservation of Mass, Conservation of Momentum, Conservation of Energy, and Equation of State (i.e. the Ideal Gas Law).

Determining pressure, temperature, and air velocity differentials throughout a system and plugging those numbers into equations that most engineers will remember from undergraduate and graduate training will define the problem that will be faced in designing the system.

Dr. Azar said, “When I focus on integral modeling as I go through the process, you’ll see how easy it is and how broad-spectrumed the applications of these are and this is going to form the first foundation for any kind of analysis that we do in electronics cooling.”

Integral modeling is applicable to any domain and will give a substantiated, independent model to ensure the system is built within the proper parameters. Taking this early step saves time and money that may have been wasted on designing a system that ultimately would not work. Integral modeling also establishes parameters under which the system can be built to save costs after deployment.

Dr. Azar explained, “If we design it for the worst case scenario, we always have the adequate margins and as a result have lesser cost of deployment.”

It is a competitive market. Integral modeling is a quick first step to ensure thermal solutions are part of a design to save on component and system costs. A few quick calculations will have a major impact on the project’s bottom line.

The survey results from Future Facilities can be found at http://www.thermalnews.com/main/news/40-percent-of-electronics-engineers-find-thermal-simulation-too-complex-and-time-consuming.

For more information about the importance of integral modeling and practical applications, watch the webinar with Dr. Kaveh Azar of Advanced Thermal Solutions, Inc. below:

Does the process of thermal design for your next project seem daunting?  Contact us.  ATS offers a  free four-hour consultation in its lab.  Email ATS at [email protected].